The kitchen smells like vanilla and almond when you’re whipping this frosting. Butter turns cloud-white in the mixer bowl, transforming from yellow sticks into something that looks like fresh snow. This Cookie Buttercream Frosting for Cozy Holidays makes every sugar cookie feel special—the kind you stack in tins for neighbors or pipe into perfect swirls for the dessert table.
I’ve made this frosting probably two hundred times. It’s the one recipe I never mess with during December because it just works. Creamy enough to spread smooth, sturdy enough to pipe tall rosettes that hold their shape. The almond extract is the secret—it tastes exactly like those frosted sugar cookies from bakeries, the ones with thick frosting that makes you close your eyes.
Why This Frosting Works
- Whips incredibly light despite being pure butter and sugar
- Almond extract creates that classic bakery flavor without tasting artificial
- Holds piped shapes perfectly for decorative cookies or simple spreading
- Makes enough for two dozen generous portions without waste
Key Ingredients
Unsalted butter (1 cup, softened): This is your base. Room temperature matters—press your finger into the stick and it should leave an indent without your finger sinking through. Too cold and you’ll get lumps. Too warm and the frosting turns greasy. I leave mine on the counter for about an hour before starting.
Vanilla extract (2 teaspoons): Pure extract only. The imitation stuff tastes tinny in buttercream where there’s nowhere to hide. You want that warm, rounded vanilla flavor that makes the whole frosting smell like a bakery.
Almond extract (½-1½ teaspoons): Here’s where the magic happens. Start with half a teaspoon if you’re nervous—it’s potent. I use a full teaspoon for that classic sugar cookie taste. Go to one and a half if you really want that bakery-style punch. This is what makes Cookie Buttercream Frosting for Cozy Holidays taste like childhood memories.
Salt (¼ teaspoon): Cuts the sweetness just enough. Without it, the frosting tastes flat and one-dimensional. With it, every flavor gets sharper and more interesting.
Powdered sugar (3 cups): Also called confectioners’ sugar. The cornstarch in it helps stabilize the frosting. Don’t substitute granulated—it won’t dissolve and you’ll get gritty frosting. Sift it if yours has lumps, but most modern brands are fine straight from the bag.
Food coloring: Optional but fun. Gel colors work better than liquid—they won’t thin your frosting. I keep red, green, and maybe gold on hand for holiday cookies.
How to Make It
Whip the butter: Put your softened butter in a large bowl. Use a hand mixer or stand mixer with the paddle attachment. Beat on high speed for 3-4 minutes. Really. It seems long but the butter needs to incorporate air. You’ll see it transform from yellow and dense to pale and fluffy. The texture changes completely—it nearly doubles in volume and looks almost white.
Add extracts and salt: Pour in your vanilla extract, almond extract (start with ½ teaspoon if unsure), and salt. Whip for another 30 seconds on high. The bowl will smell incredible. This is when I usually taste a tiny bit on my finger to check the almond level—you can always add more but you can’t take it out.
Incorporate powdered sugar gradually: Turn your mixer to medium-low. Add powdered sugar half a cup at a time. Let each addition mostly incorporate before adding the next. This prevents a sugar cloud explosion in your kitchen. I learned this the hard way—my cabinets were coated in white dust. After all three cups are in, the frosting looks thick and matte.
Whip until creamy: Crank the mixer back to high speed. Beat for 2-3 minutes. The frosting transforms again—it gets lighter, shinier, and incredibly smooth. Scrape down the bowl once during this time. You’ll know it’s ready when it holds soft peaks and looks glossy.
Frost your cookies: For simple spreading, use an offset spatula or butter knife. Scoop a generous dollop onto each cooled cookie and spread to the edges. For piped designs, fit a large piping bag with a large star tip (I use Wilton 1M). Fill the bag about halfway—easier to control. To pipe swirls, start at the cookie center and spiral outward in one smooth motion. Lift straight up at the edge for a clean finish.
Yield check: This makes about 2 cups of frosting. That’s enough for roughly 24 cookies if they’re 2.5 inches across and you’re generous with the frosting. I like a thick layer—about ¼ inch—because that’s the whole point of Cookie Buttercream Frosting for Cozy Holidays.
Tips & Variations
Adjust consistency: Too thick to spread? Add milk or heavy cream, one teaspoon at a time, beating after each addition. Too thin to pipe? Add more powdered sugar, ¼ cup at a time. The frosting should hold its shape but still feel creamy.
Color like a pro: Divide your frosting into separate bowls before adding gel colors. Start with a toothpick amount—you can always deepen the shade. Asheville tip: I keep a dedicated set of small bowls just for tinting frosting during December.
Make it chocolate: Replace ½ cup powdered sugar with ½ cup cocoa powder. Add an extra tablespoon of cream to compensate for the cocoa’s dryness.
Try different extracts: Swap almond for peppermint extract (start with ½ teaspoon—it’s strong). Or use maple extract for a cozy winter variation. Lemon extract makes this perfect for spring cookies.
Double the batch: This recipe doubles perfectly if you’re frosting a crowd’s worth of cookies. Just make sure your mixer bowl is large enough—you need room for all that air incorporation.
Storage & Pairings
Store in an airtight container at room temperature for 2 days, refrigerated for 2 weeks, or frozen for 3 months. Bring to room temperature and re-whip before using—it gets dense when cold. Pairs perfectly with classic sugar cookies, gingerbread, or even as a filling between sandwich cookies. Spread on graham crackers for a quick treat.
FAQ
Can I make this without almond extract?
Yes. Double the vanilla to 4 teaspoons total. You’ll lose that signature bakery flavor, but it’ll still taste good—just more straightforward vanilla buttercream. The almond is what makes it taste like those frosted cookies from the grocery store bakery.
Why is my frosting grainy?
Your butter was too cold or you didn’t beat it long enough. The butter needs to be truly softened and whipped until fluffy before adding sugar. If it’s already made and grainy, try beating it on high speed for another 3-4 minutes. Sometimes the friction warms it enough to smooth out.
💡 Loved this recipe? Follow Us on Pinterest for more!
Make It Your Own
This frosting turns ordinary cookies into something worth photographing. The almond extract does the heavy lifting—it’s that one ingredient that makes people ask for the recipe. Whip the butter longer than feels necessary. Add the sugar slowly. Taste as you go.
The swirled cookies look fancy but they’re just one continuous spiral motion. Start in the middle, work outward, lift up. Done. Stack them in a tin and they’ll stay perfect for days.
Easy Cookie Buttercream Frosting for Cozy Holidays
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- Whip the butter until pale and fluffy.
- Add vanilla extract, almond extract, and salt, then whip again.
- Gradually incorporate powdered sugar, mixing until thick and matte.
- Whip until creamy and glossy, then frost your cookies.